Cognitive Behavioural Psychotherapist.
If you have started considering attending therapy, you should keep in your mind that there are numerous approaches available. Among the most frequently used treatment methods are Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT).
In spite of their similarities to one another, these treatment methods have their own notable variations however. Being knowledgeable about how these therapies function will give you an opportunity to take the most appropriate decision for you. In this article we will look at 5 differences between CBT and DBT and which one is the best therapy for you?
Table of Contents
I will examine both Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) in detail. First I will start with Behavioural therapy, often known as cognitive behavioral therapy or CBT, is a well researched psychotherapy that aims to help patients recognize and alter unhelpful ways of thinking and behaving.
In the 1960s, psychiatrist Aaron Beck identified a type of negative thinking that he called “automatic negative thoughts,” which was tied to emotional problems.
CBT is often sought out for the treatment of anxiety disorders and depression, but it may also be helpful for a wide range of other mental health concerns and mental issues.
The goal of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is to modify maladaptive patterns of thinking that underlie and amplify emotional difficulties, such as depression and anxiety. CBT is predicated on the idea that the ways in which we think, feel, and act are inextricably intertwined. As a consequence, worrying thoughts and actions may emerge from holding unhelpful and irrational beliefs.
CBT is a talk therapy that aims to help patients recognize unhelpful ways of thinking and behaving and teach them new techniques for coping with their emotional pain.
Understanding how a person’s thoughts, feelings, and external actions might combine to produce maladaptive behavior is essential for spotting negative thinking.
This may include working on coping strategies with the therapist and practicing their use before using them in real-world scenarios.
In order to succeed in recovery, goal setting is essential. The client is taught by the therapist to set goals, recognize the difference between immediate and long term goals, and value both the journey and the destination equally.
Reduce the negative impacts of mental and physical illness via problem solving using cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT).
Keeping a diary to record and discuss one’s actions, symptoms, or experiences over time is one method of self-monitoring that therapists often recommend.
This may provide the therapist with the information needed to provide the best possible care.
DBT is comparable to cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) which was originally developed to treat borderline personality disorder but has now been adapted to treat a wide range of issues.
Those who struggle with emotional regulation or demonstrate self-destructive habits like binge eating, substance addiction, or intentional self-harm may benefit from this kind of therapy.
Mindfulness and emotional regulation are two more components of DBT that also target problematic thoughts and actions.
DBT is a therapy that teaches people effective methods of dealing with stress, managing their emotions, and strengthening their relationships with others. Patients who are chronically stressed yet lack appropriate coping mechanisms may benefit from this therapy.
In the 1980s, Marsha Linehan developed DBT to aid people who struggled with suicidal thoughts and were also diagnosed with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The following are common symptoms among those who suffer from BPD:
DBT was developed to help those who suffer with borderline personality disorder (BPD) manage these main symptoms by providing them with the tools they need to succeed.
Through this method, people with BPD will learn to cope with adversity and control their interpersonal interactions, ultimately improving their quality of life.
There are four DBT components:
Mindfulness:
DBT emphasizes the importance of being in the here and now and cultivating a sense of calm and equilibrium. Those who have an inconsistent sense of self and have trouble staying in the present might benefit greatly from this.
The goal of this exercise is to help you break the habit of automatically entertaining negative thoughts by forcing you to focus on the here and now.
Emotional Regulation.
Learning to control overwhelming emotions is a skill that DBT teaches its clients. People become aware that they may choose how to deal with strong or upsetting emotions. Some people may even learn to spot situations that are likely to make them feel very upset and stay away from them.
Tolerance for adversity:
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) instructs people on how to deal with tough situations, such as by helping them learn to rein in their emotions and actions so they don’t do something destructive while they’re upset.
Effectiveness in relationships:
DBT helps people learn to communicate and build rapport with others. It might help people learn to create healthy boundaries with others and be more aggressive in their interactions with them. Possibilities for better listening, conflict resolution, and friendship building are raised.
Time limited offer
✔️ Receive training in all the major schools of psychology.
✔️ You can do the courses one at a time! You can even gift one to a colleague.
✔️ A Diploma Certificate is awarded for each course successfully completed.
✔️ There is no time limit for completion – take your time and enjoy the learning.
DBT is a type of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), thus it follows many of the same ideas and principles. These include the emphasis on teaching healthy coping mechanisms and the modification of negative and unhelpful thought patterns. However, they differ in important ways that will be elaborated upon below.
Different points of focus:
Although both CBT and DBT focus on helping the client make positive changes to their way of thinking, CBT gives more attention to the client’s cognitive processes and how they might be redirected.
The goal of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is to help people become aware of and overcome cognitive distortions, including catastrophizing, mental filtering, and overgeneralizing, so that they may better manage their emotions and improve their mental health.
When compared to CBT, DBT places more emphasis on equilibrium and the connection between acceptance and change. Although it may be helpful, DBT does not stress the importance of changing one’s thoughts.
There is no rigorous technique involved with CBT; rather, the client becomes more aware and tolerant as they validate their own reality.
Difference in therapy duration
Most people who undergo CBT complete treatment in a very short amount of time, on average 6 weeks to 6 months. So that participants have something to work toward, each session will focus on overcoming a unique challenge.
When clients complete their goals in CBT, treatment is considered complete. On the other hand, DBT sessions tend to last longer so that the therapist can see the whole picture and help the client work through more than one problem.
Usually, it takes at least six months to finish all of the DBT modules, and in the worst cases, therapy can last for years.
Difference in Methods.
Almost always, a therapist works with a client alone during CBT. During therapy sessions, the therapist and client work together, and the client may be given tasks to do outside of the office.
Most DBT treatments consist of weekly group therapy in addition to weekly individual sessions.
Participants study and practice skills from one of the four modules in these sessions, which take place in a group setting to provide a safe and encouraging environment for learning and practicing.
Differences in treatment outcomes.
The goal of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is to help patients improve their outlook on life by helping them identify and change negative thinking and behavior patterns.
DBT’s overall goal is to help clients learn to better manage their emotions and strengthen their relationships with others via behavioral changes, acceptance, and validation.
CBT is used to treat a wide range of medical conditions, including:
Anxiety – Depression –The Bipolar Spectrum –Addiction- Anger – Bulimia- Panic attacks- Phobias
CBT has also been used to help people deal with a variety of issues, not only mental health problems:
Chronic pain – Separations and divorces – Grief – Insomnia – Low self worth – Conflict in relationships- Controlling stress
DBT:
Although Dialectical Behavior Therapy was first developed for people with borderline personality disorder, it has now been shown to be effective for a wide range of other mental health issues.
Depression – The Bipolar Spectrum –Anxiety that doesn’t seem to have a specific cause – PTSD- Problems focusing and paying attention are symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) – Eating Disorders – Illnesses triggered by substance abuse
DBT has also been used to help people cope with a variety of issues, not only mental health problems:
Evidence suggests that CBT AND DBT may help with a wide variety of mental health issues. Advantages include:
CBT is one of the most researched therapies in part because of the clarity with which its goals and results can be stated.
Evidence from meta-analyses suggests that cognitive behavioral therapy is effective for a wide range of problems, including anxiety disorders like OCD and PTSD, anger management difficulties, drug abuse, and generalized stress .
It has been shown that online CBT sessions are just as effective as in-person ones (Hofman et al., 2012).
Studies show CBT may be effective with Children and adolescents in treating depressive and anxious symptoms in this age range (Oud et al., 2019).
Analysis of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for insomnia reveals its usefulness in preventing relapses of primary insomnia (Okajima et al., 2011).
1. What are the main differences between CBT and DBT?
CBT focuses on identifying and changing negative thought patterns and behaviors to improve emotional regulation and mental health. It typically involves individual sessions with a therapist and is known for its short-term approach. DBT, while based on CBT principles, incorporates group therapy sessions and emphasizes emotional regulation, mindfulness, distress tolerance, and interpersonal effectiveness. DBT is often longer in duration and originally designed to treat borderline personality disorder, but is now used for a broader range of issues.
2. How do I know if CBT or DBT is right for me?
The choice between CBT and DBT depends on your specific mental health needs and goals. CBT might be more suitable if you’re dealing with anxiety, depression, or other problems where changing thought patterns could be beneficial. DBT could be a better option if you’re struggling with emotional regulation, self-harm, or borderline personality disorder. It’s important to consult with a mental health professional who can assess your situation and recommend the most appropriate therapy.
3. Can CBT and DBT be effective for children and adolescents?
Yes, both CBT and DBT have been adapted and found to be effective for children and adolescents. CBT can help young individuals manage anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues by teaching them coping strategies and how to change negative thought patterns. DBT has been used to assist adolescents with emotional regulation and improve their interpersonal relationships. However, the specific techniques and focus may be adapted to be age-appropriate and meet the developmental needs of younger clients.
Sign up for our Excellent Diploma course in CBT.